TikTok star accused of hiring hit man. Hemlock and magic spells at a murder trial. Plus, the Bexley Box.

May 28, 2026

🎯 Core Theme & Purpose

This episode of Dateline True Crime Weekly delves into several chilling criminal cases, offering a deep dive into the legal proceedings and investigative details. The unique angle lies in its comprehensive coverage of ongoing trials and the behind-the-scenes efforts of law enforcement and news producers to bring these stories to light. Listeners interested in true crime, legal dramas, and the complexities of criminal justice will find this episode particularly engaging.

📋 Detailed Content Breakdown

Magic Spells and Murder Trial: The episode begins with a discussion of a trial in San Diego, California, where a man is accused of hiring people to cast “magic spells” on his wife. This unusual aspect of the case highlights the bizarre motives and methods sometimes encountered in criminal investigations. The producers are actively covering the breaking crime news, with the trial now in its second week.
Larry and Maya Ray: A Complex Case: A significant portion of the episode focuses on the murder trial of Larry Ray in Colorado, accused of killing his wife Maya Ray. Prosecutors allege he used animal tranquilizers. The case is marked by the disappearance of Maya, the absence of her body, and accusations of a potential affair and the use of magic spells as part of the alleged motive.
TikTok Star’s Murder Plot Allegations: The narrative shifts to Los Angeles, where a TikTok star, Gabby Gonzalez, faces charges for allegedly attempting to hire a hitman to kill her ex-boyfriend, Jack Avery, who is also the father of her child. The prosecution claims this was part of a complex plot involving Gabby’s father, Francisco Gonzalez, and her then-boyfriend, Kai Cordry, with funds allegedly transferred for the assassination.
The Mysterious Disappearance of Maya Millete: The case of Maya Millete, a working mother from Chula Vista, California, who vanished in 2021, is revisited. Despite extensive searches and her husband, Larry Ray’s, arrest and trial, Maya’s body has never been found. The prosecution’s case hinges on circumstantial evidence, including the alleged use of poison, an affair, and even magic spells, while the defense questions the evidence and suggests other possibilities.
The Murders of the Cannizzaro Family: In New Jersey, Paul Cannizzaro was convicted of murdering his younger brother Keith, Keith’s wife, and their two children. His sentencing hearing is detailed, with emotional statements from surviving family members highlighting the devastating impact of his actions. The judge’s sentencing reflects the severity of the crimes, condemning Paul as a “quadruple murderer.”
The Bexley Box Initiative: Kirsten Brydigan, the sister of the victim Jared Brydigan, who was shot and killed after stopping his car to address a tire-blocking incident, discusses her initiative called the “Bexley Box.” This is a kit designed to help comfort children in traumatic situations, inspired by her niece Bexley’s experience after witnessing her father’s murder. The program has expanded significantly with support from Walmart and various law enforcement agencies.

💡 Key Insights & Memorable Moments

The prosecution’s case against Larry Ray is built on a foundation of unusual elements, including alleged attempts to use “magic spells” and animal tranquilizers, underscoring the often-unconventional nature of criminal motives.
Kirsten Brydigan’s creation of the “Bexley Box” serves as a powerful testament to turning personal tragedy into a force for good, providing comfort and resources for children affected by crime.
“We are going to try to kill your ex-husband. I’m going to need $10,000.” - Allegedly spoken by Kai Cordry to an undercover officer in the investigation of TikTok star Gabby Gonzalez.
The judge’s sentencing of Paul Cannizzaro, referring to him as a “quadruple murderer who slaughtered innocent children,” powerfully conveys the gravity of his crimes.
The detail that some of the “magic spells” allegedly requested by Larry Ray involved having Maya’s bones broken to prevent her from leaving highlights the disturbing desperation and control tactics alleged in the case.

🎯 Actionable Takeaways

Support victim advocacy initiatives: Consider donating to or volunteering with organizations like the Bexley Box or similar groups that provide direct support and comfort to victims of crime, especially children.
Understand the complexities of the legal system: The cases discussed illustrate the challenges faced by prosecutors in building cases with circumstantial evidence and the importance of thorough investigation.
Recognize the ripple effects of crime: The impact of violent crime extends far beyond the immediate victims, affecting families, communities, and even law enforcement personnel, as seen in the emotional testimony and the creation of the Bexley Box.
Stay informed about ongoing legal battles: Following true crime stories from reputable sources like Dateline provides insight into the justice system and fosters a greater understanding of societal issues.
Appreciate the role of evidence: The details about forensic analysis, witness testimony, and the challenges of presenting evidence in court (e.g., the Brydigan case) highlight the critical importance of accurate and admissible evidence in achieving justice.

👥 Guest Information

Haley Barber: Dateline Producer.
Area of Expertise: Investigative journalism, focusing on true crime and legal proceedings.
Qualifications: Her role as a Dateline producer involves deep dives into complex cases, interviewing key figures, and reporting on the intricacies of criminal trials.
Key Contributions: Provided detailed updates on the Larry Ray trial, the Gabby Gonzalez case, the Paul Cannizzaro sentencing, and the ongoing development of the Bexley Box initiative. She offered crucial context and behind-the-scenes insights from the courtroom and investigations.
Mentioned Resources: The Bexley Box initiative.

This was a solo episode by the host of Dateline True Crime Weekly.